Skip to content
TagSentry
Blog

Guide · Rules and enforcement

Cookie walls: are they legal, and what about pay or OK?

Where the EDPB and regulators in France, Germany, the Netherlands, Denmark and the UK stand on cookie walls and pay-or-OK, with a test of 174 EU sites.

Shaun Brown · November 18, 2026 · 6 min read

The short answer

A cookie wall blocks a site until the visitor accepts tracking. If refusing leaves no way in at all, EU regulators treat the consent as not freely given, and the Dutch regulator says it is "generally not allowed". A "pay or OK" wall, where visitors either accept or pay for a version without tracking, is accepted by regulators in France, Germany, Denmark and the UK under conditions: a reasonable price, the same service either way, and separate choices for separate purposes. For very large platforms the EDPB says a bare choice between consent and a fee will in most cases fail.

A cookie wall is a consent banner you can't get past without saying yes. The page behind it stays hidden or locked until you accept tracking cookies.

There are two kinds. A hard wall offers Accept and nothing else: refuse and you don't get in. A pay-or-OK wall (also called "consent or pay") offers a second door: accept tracking, or pay for a subscription that comes without it. German publishers call the paid door a "Pur-Abo".

A banner that offers Accept and Settings but no Reject on the first screen isn't a wall, since you can still refuse a layer down. It has its own problems, covered in our GDPR cookie banner guide.

Where each regulator stands

WhoWhenPosition
EDPB (all EU regulators together)4 May 2020Access must not depend on accepting cookies. Behind a wall with only "Accept cookies", the visitor "is not presented with a genuine choice", so the consent isn't valid (Guidelines 05/2020, paras. 39 to 41)
Netherlands, Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens7 March 2019, and its current guidanceWebsites must stay accessible when a visitor refuses tracking cookies. A cookie wall without a reasonable alternative is "generally not allowed"
France, CNIL16 May 2022No blanket ban (the Conseil d'État ruled in June 2020 that the CNIL couldn't impose one). A wall is judged case by case: there must be a real and fair alternative, and if it's paid, the price must be reasonable
Denmark, Datatilsynet20 February 2023Consent or pay can be valid. Gul og Gratis's price of 29 kr a month wasn't unreasonably high. Jysk Fynske Medier's wall failed because the free version with consent didn't broadly match the paid one. Statistics need their own consent unless they're shown to be needed for the paid version
Germany, DSK (federal and state regulators)22 March 2023Tracking can rest on consent when a tracking-free alternative exists, even a paid one, as long as it's an equivalent service at a normal market price and consent is granular where purposes differ
UK, ICO23 January 2025Data protection law "does not prohibit" consent or pay. The test is power imbalance, an appropriate fee, an equivalent core service, and choices presented equally. The ICO says the guidance is under review after the Data (Use and Access) Act
EDPB, for large online platforms17 April 2024"In most cases" a binary choice between consent and a fee won't give valid consent on a large platform. Platforms should consider a free option without behavioural advertising

None of these regulators defends a hard wall. The disagreement is over the paid option. France, Germany, Denmark and the UK accept it under conditions, and the Dutch guidance leaves room for a "reasonable alternative".

What makes a pay-or-OK wall acceptable

The regulators don't agree on everything, but the same four conditions keep coming up.

  1. A fair price. Denmark asks whether the fee is so high that visitors have no real choice in practice. The CNIL wants a reasonable price, sets no figure, and encourages publishers to publish how they set theirs.
  2. The same service either way. Danish and German regulators both say the paid version and the free-with-consent version have to cover broadly the same content. Jysk Fynske Medier failed on exactly this.
  3. Separate choices for separate purposes. A yes to ads isn't a yes to everything. Denmark ordered both publishers to let visitors consent to statistics on their own, or to show statistics were needed for the paid version.
  4. No tracking behind the paid door. Germany's DSK says subscribers who give no extra consent should get only what's strictly necessary.

The wall still has to meet every other consent rule: clear information, nothing pre-ticked, and a way to withdraw.

What we saw on 174 large European sites

On 18 November 2026 we drew 200 random sites from the top 20,000 of the Tranco top-sites list, all on EU country domains (.de, .fr, .at, .nl, .it, .pl and others). We loaded each homepage once in a fresh browser set to the country's language, clicked nothing, and read the banner's first screen. We don't name the sites.

174 loaded, and 88 showed us a consent banner.

What the first screen offeredBanners
A free Reject (or "only necessary", "continue without accepting")52 of 88
Accept, or a paid subscription without tracking ads (pay or OK)15 of 88
Accept and Settings, with no Reject21 of 88
Accept and nothing else (a hard wall)0 of 88

Every pay-or-OK wall was on a German, Austrian, French or Spanish domain: 8 of the 31 German banners, 3 of the 4 Austrian, 3 of 11 French and 1 of 5 Spanish. We saw none on Dutch, Belgian, Polish or Italian sites. Most were news publishers, plus a fuel-price site, a legal forum and a cinema guide.

8 of the 15 showed a monthly price on the first screen, from €1.99 to €4.99. All three French ones labelled the button "Refuser et s'abonner" (refuse and subscribe), so the button that says "refuse" starts a subscription.

The test has limits. We visited from a US connection, and sites that show their banner only to EU addresses don't show it to us, so the real share of pay-or-OK walls may be higher. We didn't open Settings, so we can't say whether those 21 banners let visitors refuse for free one layer down.

Big platforms are a separate case

The EDPB's 2024 opinion was requested by the Dutch, Norwegian and Hamburg regulators. It covers large online platforms only, and the EDPB said it would write broader guidelines on consent or pay later. When we checked on 18 November 2026, those hadn't been published.

The European Commission acted under a different law. On 23 April 2025 it fined Meta €200 million under the Digital Markets Act for offering EU users only the binary "consent or pay" choice between March and November 2024. The Digital Markets Act applies only to the "gatekeepers" it designates, so this decision doesn't reach an ordinary publisher.

If you run an ordinary site

Most sites don't need a wall. A shop, a SaaS site or a blog doesn't sell its content, so the regulators' conditions (a priced subscription to an equivalent service) don't fit.

The simplest pattern is a banner with Reject all next to Accept all on the first screen, where the site works whatever the visitor picks. Our test of 92 consent banners shows what that looks like in practice, and you can check your own site's cookies to see what runs before anyone answers.

TagSentry's banner

TagSentry's banner puts Reject all and Accept all side by side on the first screen, with the same look, and nothing beyond the necessary is pre-ticked. Its first screen leaves the page open, so visitors can keep reading while they decide.

In the EU, EEA and UK it asks first. One line of code sets every Google consent signal to denied before any tag runs (Consent Mode, Google's way of telling its tags what a visitor allowed). Say no once and our banner won't ask again on that browser for at least six months.

Every answer is saved as a consent record, kept for 24 months with no IP address or browser details, and exported as a CSV. How consent works has the detail for each region.

Sources

  1. EDPB: Guidelines 05/2020 on consent under Regulation 2016/679 (4 May 2020), paras. 39 to 41
  2. EDPB: Opinion 08/2024 on valid consent in the context of consent or pay models implemented by large online platforms (17 April 2024)
  3. EDPB: 'Consent or Pay' models should offer real choice (17 April 2024)
  4. CNIL: Cookie walls, la CNIL publie des premiers critères d'évaluation (16 May 2022)
  5. Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens: Websites moeten toegankelijk blijven bij weigeren tracking cookies (7 March 2019)
  6. Autoriteit Persoonsgegevens: Tracking cookies
  7. Datenschutzkonferenz: Beschluss, Bewertung von Pur-Abo-Modellen auf Websites (22 March 2023)
  8. Datatilsynet: Brug af cookie walls (20 February 2023)
  9. Datatilsynet: Gul og Gratis' brug af cookie walls (February 2023)
  10. ICO: Consent or pay, about this guidance (23 January 2025)
  11. European Commission: Commission finds Apple and Meta in breach of the Digital Markets Act (IP/25/1085, 23 April 2025)
  12. Tranco: a research-oriented top sites ranking