The short answer
Usually not an EU-style "ask first" banner. Most US state laws let you run trackers by default, as long as visitors can opt out of having their data sold or shared for advertising, and about a dozen states say you must honour the browser's privacy signal (GPC) automatically. In practice you need a "Your Privacy Choices" link that works, tags that stop when someone opts out, and a record that they did. Visitors from the EU or UK still need a banner that asks first.
Opt-in versus opt-out
Privacy laws either ask first or let visitors opt out.
- Opt-in (the EU, UK, Brazil and others): you ask before setting non-essential cookies or running trackers, and nothing runs until the visitor says yes.
- Opt-out (California and most US state laws): you may run trackers by default, but visitors must be able to say stop, and then you have to stop.
So a US business with US visitors probably doesn't need a wall over the page. It does need an opt-out that works.
What California expects
California's privacy law gives people the right to opt out of the "sale" or "sharing" of their personal information, and regulators treat many advertising pixels, the Meta Pixel among them, as sharing. So you need:
- A clear link, usually labelled "Your Privacy Choices" or "Do Not Sell or Share My Personal Information".
- Opt-outs that stop the relevant tags.
- The Global Privacy Control signal a browser sends, honoured as an opt-out.
One of California's first public enforcement actions was largely about that last point. In 2022 Sephora paid $1.2 million, and its settlement named GPC as a required way to opt out. In February 2026 Disney agreed to pay $2.75 million, a record, for not honouring opt-outs across all its streaming services.
Broken tools count too. In 2025 California's privacy agency fined Todd Snyder $345,178, partly because its opt-out tool was misconfigured for 40 days.
The privacy-signal states
Global Privacy Control is a setting in some browsers and extensions that tells every site "don't sell or share my data". About a dozen states now require businesses to treat it as a valid opt-out, among them California, Colorado, Connecticut, Texas, Oregon and New Jersey.
States keep being added, so check the current statutes before you rely on any list, ours included.
Few visitors send the signal today, but from 1 January 2027 a California law (AB 566) requires every browser to offer one.
What the demand letters usually claim
The other risk is lawsuits and demand letters under California's Invasion of Privacy Act (CIPA), a law first written for wiretaps. Plaintiffs argue that pixels, chat widgets and session recorders sending data to third parties amount to eavesdropping, especially when scripts send data before the visitor has had a chance to choose.
SB 690 changed part of this. Governor Newsom signed it on 30 September 2026, and from 1 January 2027 private plaintiffs can no longer sue over websites under CIPA's "pen register" section (638.51). Only the Attorney General can. It also reaches back to pending suits filed since 1 January 2025.
It leaves the wiretap and eavesdropping claims (sections 631 and 632) in place, so the usual advice stands: know exactly what your site sends before anyone agrees.
A sensible US setup
| Visitor | What they should get |
|---|---|
| California and GPC states, no signal | Tracking runs, with a visible privacy choices link that works |
| California and GPC states, GPC on | Treated as opted out of selling and sharing |
| Other US states | Tracking runs, with a way to opt out |
| EU, EEA, UK | A banner that asks first, with Reject and Accept equally easy |
Whichever row a visitor falls in, keep a record of what they chose, for long enough that you can show it to someone who asks.
Should US visitors default to tracking on?
In opt-out states, most people who set these up give US visitors Google Consent Mode granted by default and switch it to denied when someone opts out. The catch is the demand-letter risk above. Some businesses pick stricter defaults in California anyway, especially for advertising pixels.
A middle path: start every visitor at denied before any tag runs, then switch tracking on moments after the page loads unless the visitor has opted out. That way no tag starts before the page knows whether the visitor has opted out, and visitors who haven't are still tracked.
What a US visit looks like, tested
On 8 October 2026 we opened tagsentry.ai twice in a fresh Firefox from a US address, in a state outside California and the GPC states: once with the privacy signal off, once with it on. No clicks. We recorded every request to another site in the first eight seconds, the Consent Mode states and what appeared on screen.
| Privacy signal off | Privacy signal on | |
|---|---|---|
| Banner or wall | None | None |
| Other sites contacted before any click | Our consent CDN only | Our consent CDN only |
| Consent Mode at the start | Everything denied | Everything denied |
| Consent Mode moments later | Advertising and analytics granted | Advertising denied, analytics granted |
| On screen | Nothing | "Opt-out request honored. Your browser sent Global Privacy Control." with an OK button, and a "Your Privacy Choices" button |
tagsentry.ai runs no Google tags or pixels, so the Consent Mode states are what any Google tag on the page would read.
So a visitor without the signal gets a clear page and is tracked by default, and one with it is opted out of advertising before they click anything. Run the same two visits on your own site, and check what Google's tags received.
How TagSentry handles it
TagSentry applies opt-out rules to US visitors, with no banner by default in any US state. California and the 11 states that require the privacy signal get a small "Your Privacy Choices" button. Elsewhere the page stays clear, and the button appears once a visitor has made a choice.
In every state, GPC counts as an opt-out of advertising: ad tags and pixels are held, Google's ad signals are denied, and analytics keeps running.
EU and UK visitors get a banner that asks first, all from the same one line of code. Every choice is kept as a record for 24 months.
Sources
- California AG: Sephora settlement over Global Privacy Control
- CPPA: Todd Snyder enforcement announcement
- Hunton: California AG record settlement with Disney over opt-out rights
- CookieScript: Universal opt-out mechanisms by US state
- DLA Piper: Governor Newsom signs SB 690 (October 2026)
- IAPP: California requires an in-browser opt-out preference signal
- Shumaker: The CIPA demand letters flooding businesses