Skip to content
TagSentry

CookieFirst alternative: TagSentry vs CookieFirst

CookieFirst is a Dutch, Google-certified banner, part of iubenda since 2025, with 44 languages and IAB TCF on its Plus plan. TagSentry Consent is free to 10,000 page views per site, then from $9. Live event monitoring is its own product, free to 250,000 events.

Checked November 13, 2026. Written by TagSentry, so weigh it accordingly.

Pick CookieFirst if

  • You run programmatic ads and need IAB TCF from a Google-certified CMP
  • You want a plugin for WordPress, Shopify or Shopware
  • You need a banner language beyond our 32

Pick TagSentry if

  • You want consent records kept on the free plan too
  • You want the browser's privacy signal treated as an opt-out across the US
  • You want to see, live, which events fire and where they go

The short answer

CookieFirst suits sites that want a European banner with plenty of options: it's on Google's list of certified CMPs, offers IAB TCF on its Plus plan, speaks 44 languages and has plugins for WordPress, Shopify and Shopware. TagSentry suits sites on Google Tag Manager that want consent records on every plan, a price that starts free and grows with page views, and a live view of which events fire and where they go.

What CookieFirst offers

For programmatic ads, CookieFirst is on Google's list of certified CMPs (consent management platforms), and its Plus plan supports IAB TCF. Serving personalised ads through AdSense or Ad Manager in the EEA, the UK or Switzerland needs both.

It installs as a plugin on WordPress, Shopify and Shopware, and has a template in Tag Manager's Community Template Gallery. Its help centre lists 44 languages, and it says it can add one on request within a week.

CookieFirst is based in Amsterdam, and stores consent data with OVH in Germany and France. It joined iubenda, part of the team.blue group, in January 2025.

What you get with TagSentry

CookieFirst lists consent audit trails on its Plus plan. We keep consent records for 24 months on every plan, Free included, with a CSV export. Each site is free up to 10,000 page views a month, then $9, $19, $49 or $99 as it grows.

Each visitor gets the rules their place's law asks for, with nothing for you to set up. The EU, UK, Switzerland, Brazil, Quebec and more ask first. Every US state gets opt-out rules, and the browser's privacy signal (GPC) counts as an opt-out of advertising there, automatically.

Monitoring shows every event, where it was sent and which fields it carried. You get one email when an event that matters stops, and one when it recovers. Each site keeps its records and events in the EU or the US, on every plan.

What we found on 62 CookieFirst sites

On 9 November 2026 we drew 20,000 sites at random from the Tranco top-sites list, on European country domains, and found 77 that load CookieFirst. CookieFirst serves each site's banner settings in a public file. We read that file for 62 of them, then visited each homepage once from the US.

What we sawSites
Showed the banner to our US visitor54 of 62
Sent nothing to any tracker before a click35 of 54
Sent only Google's cookieless pings before a click5 of 54
Sent data to trackers before any click14 of 54
Had Reject (or similar) on the banner's first screen43 of 54
Still sent data after Reject8 of 43

Most sites held their trackers until a click. Where data went out before a click, it went to Google on 10 sites, Microsoft on 5, and Meta or TikTok on 2 each. Seven of the 8 sites that kept sending after Reject had already sent before the click.

The settings file explains some of what we saw:

  • 15 of 62 sites had Reject on the first screen switched off, so Reject sat one screen deeper.
  • 8 sites showed the banner only in the EU and a short list of other places (the UK, Switzerland, California, Quebec and a few more). For our visitor in Nevada, CookieFirst recorded every category as accepted, without a banner, and 6 of the 8 sent data to trackers.
  • CookieFirst has a setting for the privacy signals GPC and Do Not Track. It was off on all 62 sites.

We saw each homepage once, from the US, so a European visitor may see something different on the sites that hide the banner elsewhere. We can't see why a tag ran. Our Consent Mode check shows how to test your own site in ten minutes.

CookieFirst's plans and ours

Prices from each vendor's site on 9 November 2026. CookieFirst prices in euros; ours are in dollars.

CookieFirstTagSentry Consent
Free1 third-party script, 1 language, a one-time cookie scanUp to 10,000 page views a month, per site
Entry paidBasic: €9 a month per domain (€99 a year)$9 a month, up to 100,000 page views
NextPlus: €19 a month per domain (€209 a year), adds consent audit trails and IAB TCF$19, $49, $99, then $10 per extra million page views

CookieFirst's paid plans carry a soft limit of 250,000 page views per domain a month, and bigger sites get a custom offer.

How to switch from CookieFirst

  1. Scan your site free to see whether your banner stops your trackers.
  2. Create a site and copy its one line.
  3. Paste our line first in <head>, above your Tag Manager code. Keep CookieFirst running for now. Our line sees it, stays out of its way, and starts watching your events.
  4. When you're ready, remove CookieFirst (its script, plugin or Tag Manager template), then choose our banner in Settings › Install straight away, or visitors may see two banners. There's nothing new to paste.
  5. Connect Tag Manager if you use it. We sort every tag by purpose and show you the plan, and nothing is written until you approve. Every change is a new version in your container, whose notes name the one it replaced.

Consent records stay with the tool that collected them, so export CookieFirst's first. Visitors are asked again the first time they see the new banner.

Other questions

Is CookieFirst part of iubenda now?

Yes. iubenda, part of the team.blue group, bought CookieFirst in January 2025. CookieFirst still runs as its own product. Our iubenda comparison covers iubenda itself.

Does CookieFirst honour GPC?

It has a setting for it. On the 62 sites we read, none had it switched on. Our guide to US cookie banner rules covers where the signal is binding.

Can I keep one account for several sites?

Yes. Each site is priced on its own usage, so a few small sites can all stay free. From the second site on, we ask for a card on file.

Can I check my current CookieFirst setup first?

Yes. The free scan checks whether your site has a banner and whether it stops your trackers. It's one page load from the US, and it's not legal advice.

Switching from CookieFirst? Start with a free scan.

Start with a free scan. We check for a cookie banner and whether it stops your trackers. It takes under a minute, with no account.